Victim or Offender? Forced Criminality, Electronic Evidence, and the Protection of Vietnamese Trafficking Victims in Southeast Asian Scam Compounds

 

Author: Tong, Thi Thu Trang

Abstract: Cyber-scam compounds documented in Cambodia, Myanmar and Laos pose a classification problem: a returnee’s devices may document extensive online fraud while revealing little about the coercive conditions in which the acts occurred. This doctrinal legal-policy study examines Vietnam’s non-punishment rule, ASEAN guidance and electronic-evidence law through the concept of evidentiary asymmetry. It distinguishes three mechanisms: unequal availability of offense and coercion records, interpretive ambiguity in apparently voluntary digital conduct, and institutional sequencing that can prioritize offense-oriented inquiries before coercion evidence is preserved. The analysis finds that participation records cannot, without contextual examination, establish autonomy or exclude trafficking, while victim status cannot automatically negate responsibility for every act. It develops a triggered, dual-track preservation framework linking initial screening, parallel evidence collection, a time-sensitive direct-consequence assessment and a reasoned prosecutorial decision. The framework identifies practical safeguards for cross-border data requests, including evidence potentially exculpatory to an exploited person. Vietnam is an instructive case because its 2024 anti-trafficking legislation expressly addresses offending that directly results from trafficking, while its criminal procedure recognizes electronic data. The argument is applicable more broadly wherever digital systems record harmful acts more reliably than coercive circumstances.

Keywords: electronic evidence, forced criminality, human trafficking, non-punishment, scam compounds, Vietnam